THE TESTAMENT
BY ERIC VAN LUSTBADER

Review by Diana Bane

 


Lustbader has been writing savvy international political thrillers for about twenty years, and with this book injects a religious element to his proven, fast-paced formula. One assumes this is to attract the many readers who put Da Vinci Code over the top, and his publishers have obviously allocated a marketing budget to reflect their desire to cash in on the trend.

The author has done his homework in that regard, as referenced in the two page Author Note at the end of the book. Unfortunately, being faithful to historical fact isn’t enough to make a novel work, and in this case the historical background is misleading -- there is very little real exploration of religion here, historical or contemporary; it‘s all surface, all mere trappings. The plot hinges on a centuries-old conflict between the Gnostic Observantines and the Knights of St. Clement, the former being the good guys in the duality. These two groups are fictional, but the fictional Observantines are based (the author tells us) on the real Order of Franciscan Observantines, who had Christian Gnostic beliefs and were disbanded by a 13th century pope for that reason. They went underground instead, and have since -- fictionally anyway -- been pursued by the Knights, making them opponents of the Catholic Church. The Order (meaning the Gnostic Observantines) has in its keeping certain items, notably a Testament written by Jesus himself, and a healing elixir called The Quintessence, which could shake up the Church; it is the mission of the Knights to seize these things. The two groups, Order and Knights, have over the passage of time become secularized (we are told), though together they live and operate in a secret, underground world called the Voire Dei. This setup is a contemporary conspiracy theorist’s dream.

Enter Bravo, aka Braverman Shaw, the hero, chosen heir and successor to his father Dexter Shaw, member of The Order and Keeper of the sacred stash. Dexter is assassinated in the opening pages before he can impart his secrets to his son, and the chase is on. Bravo, as new Keeper, must find the sacred stash in order to protect the Testament and the Quintessence. Bravo has a Guardian, as Keepers in the Order have always had, but his is a young woman named Jenny Logan … with whom he is soon in love, of course; and of course their path both to each other and to safety does not run smooth.

Lustbader knows how to pace, to keep those pages turning, and his plotting, if convoluted, is so good that readers don’t have time to worry much about lack of depth in his characters. The plot is basically a chase and a quest as Bravo and Jenny pursue clues that Dexter Shaw left in the form of ciphers, planted in various locations, like a big, complicated treasure hunt. This part is fun, as we go from the coast of Brittany -- including a scenic side trip to Mont St. Michel -- to Venice, to Rome, to ancient Trebizond on the east coast of the Black Sea. The Venice sections are particularly enjoyable.

But the novel as a whole is an elaborate disappointment. There are hints here and there, dropped like little nuggets into the fast-moving stream of action, that the author might have made much more of his underlying thematic material than turns out to be the case. Nothing that happens quite illuminates Jenny’s statement early on (page 109): "My faith [is] in what the Order represents: a group of sane men working in an insane world for the betterment of mankind." I thought the aforementioned little nuggets were suggestive of the author’s deeper beliefs about our "insane world", and that is what I would have like to seen explored in some depth. For example, the assertion that we are approaching the Age of the New Crusades, a time when Islamic Radicalism will confront the Christian West. (Which may not be truly Christian, thus adding more depth to the problems that are not explored.)

A book of this sort needs to come to a satisfying conclusion, after the long, long chase. That does not happen in The Testament. I, for one, felt cheated and let down. I know Eric Van Lustbader can do better than this.

Return to Winter 2006 Table of Contents

© 2006 SPINETINGLER Magazine - All rights reserved
FEATURED BOOKS